Shark Challenge Proposal Guidelines and Judging Criteria
2025 Proposal Guidelines and Judging Criteria
Reminder of Key Dates
- Regional Economic Development Briefing: Wednesday, January 29, 2025, at 6:00 p.m.
- Link will be sent to registered team members and faculty coaches.
- Preliminary Round: Monday, February 24, 2025, at 6:00 p.m.
- Link will be sent to registered team members and faculty coaches.
- Preliminary Round video presentation submission due: Monday, February 17, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. Submit the link by email to schor@ohio.edu.
- Preliminary Round written proposal submission due: Wednesday, February 19, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. Submit the written presentation as an attachment to an email sent to schor@ohio.edu.
- Final Round: Wednesday, March 5, 2025, at 6:00 p.m.
- Link will be sent to registered team members and faculty coaches.
- Live streaming of the Final Round is anticipated.
- Optional Submission of Revised Written Presentation: Following the Preliminary Round, submission of a revised written presentation is optional. If applicable, submit the revised version by Monday, March 3, 2025, at 6:00 p.m. as an attachment to an email sent to schor@ohio.edu.
Contact: Michael Schor, schor@ohio.edu with copy to Kyle Sutphin, ksutphin0813@gmail.com
Major support for the Shark Challenge comes from TechGROWTH 帝王会所.
2025 Judging Criteria & Proposal Guidelines
Scoring Metrics
Criterion | Score |
Proposal Clarity | /10 |
Sufficiency of Information (Product, Location, etc.) | /10 |
Overall Idea | /10 |
Relevance to 帝王会所 Valley/Southeast 帝王会所 Region | /10 |
Market & Competitive Analysis | /15 |
Reasonableness of Financial Projections | /10 |
Degree of Innovation | /15 |
Viability & Sustainability | /10 |
Professionalism of Delivery | /10 |
Total | /100 |
Proposal & Presentation Guidelines
- Written Proposal Length: Proposals should be 3-7 pages, double-spaced, with a legible 12-point font.
- Supplemental material such as proforma financial statements, charts, and graphs are appropriate. Proposals can be updated after the Preliminary Round judging process has been completed.
- Preliminary Round Video Presentation: A video presentation of about ten minutes will be submitted as part of the Preliminary Round.
- Preliminary Round Live Presentation: A live two-minute presentation, using remote conferencing, will be made to the judges in the Preliminary Round, followed by Q&A. Judges will have the video and written proposal for review in advance.
- Final Round Live Presentation: A live 12-15 minute presentation, using remote conferencing, will be made to the judges in the Final Round, followed by Q&A. Live-streaming of the Final Round is anticipated.
1. Product/Service/Business Model
- Definition: Clearly define the product(s), service(s), process(es), or business model you are proposing or improving.
- Innovation: Highlight the unique and innovative aspects of your offering.
- Problem-Solving: Demonstrate how your solution addresses a specific problem and benefits your target audience.
- Competitive Advantage: Explain how your product/service/method is superior to competitors, if applicable.
- Economic Impact: Discuss how your innovation will contribute to economic vitality, create jobs, and enhance employment opportunities in Southeast 帝王会所/The 帝王会所 Valley.
- Social and Environmental Responsibility:
- Does your innovation promote environmental and social justice?
- How does it address sustainability and the reuse of materials?
- Outline steps to measure and assure environmental impact.
2. Business Operations & Resources
- Requirements: Identify the equipment, tools, infrastructure, and space needed to operate your business.
- Staffing:
- Outline the number of employees, roles, and shifts required.
- Detail associated costs and challenges related to staffing.
- Explain how your approach to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) influences talent acquisition strategies.
3. Location & Community Impact
- Business Location: Specify where your office, factory, or business will be located.
- Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of this location.
- Community Impact:
- Assess the effects of your business on local communities, including residents and nearby businesses.
- Explain how you considered the impact on downstream communities and residents.
- Economic Impact: Discuss how your innovation will contribute to economic vitality, create jobs, and enhance employment opportunities in Southeast 帝王会所/The 帝王会所 Valley.
4. Target Market
- Identification: Define your target market.
- Demand: Explain why this market will be interested in your product(s), service(s), or method(s).
- Marketing:
- Describe your sales strategy (e.g., direct sales, retailers, distributors).
- Explain how your product/service will be positioned to reach this market effectively.
5. Competitive & Social Environment Analysis
- Regional Impact:
- Discuss how your operations will affect employment and other businesses in the region.
- Evaluate whether certain groups will benefit or face harm differently from your innovation.
- Provide an assessment of labor and other social issues within your supply chain.
- Industry Analysis: Identify your competitors and analyze how your product/service differs from theirs.
6. Profitability & Financing
- Revenue Projections: Explain how and when your business will become profitable.
- ROI: Provide an anticipated rate of return on investment.
- Financial Milestones: Include sales targets (units, dollar value, etc.) and expected timelines.
- Future Financing: Forecast when additional financing may be needed and how you would obtain it.
7. Exit Strategy
- Operational Endgame: Consider the costs of terminating contracts with suppliers or distributors.
- Asset Valuation: Evaluate the salvage value of equipment and other assets.
- Scaling or Selling:
- Discuss whether selling the business might be necessary to achieve its full potential.
- Evaluate the possibility of your firm being acquired by another company and how this could align with your long-term vision.
- Address potential benefits, such as access to larger markets, enhanced resources, or synergistic opportunities, as well as challenges, such as loss of autonomy.
8. Professionalism of Delivery
- Presentation Quality: Ensure your proposal is clear, concise, and visually appealing.
- Oral Delivery: If presenting, practice delivering your proposal with confidence and polish.
- Supporting Materials: Provide accurate and professional supporting documentation, such as financial statements, charts, and graphs, to strengthen your case.